Grading Rubric For Paper #1 What follows is an explanation of the grading breakdown for paper #1:

Introduction:
Does the writer do a good job of introducing the issue under consideration by providing sufficient context and a clear indication of what the essay is about?
15 points

Claim:
Is the claim clear, compelling, complex, and contestable?
15 points

Organization:
Is the argument well-organized? Are the ideas presented in a clear, logical, and convincing manner?
20 points

Evidence:
Does the writer present sufficient evidence in support of his or her claims? If the writer is using secondary sources, are these adequately cited according to MLA guidelines?
20 points

Spelling, Punctuation, Grammar, and Style:
Is the essay written in a competent style with few or no spelling or punctuation errors? Do awkward syntax and grammar muddle important ideas?
10 points


Overall Strength of the Argument:
Taking everything into consideration, does the writer make a convincing and coherent case?
20 points  ¶ 10:05 AM